Hi there, Thanks if you filled in the evaluation for the computer club sessions in December. Here is general feedback from the online form followed by some anonymised personal feedback that we collected in person.
Feedback from online form
Evaluation of the Computer Club at Todmorden Makery
Summary structured using green, yellow, and red categories
Green: working well / clear positives
- Good level of interest and sustained engagement.
- Strong value placed on meeting people and social contact for computer enthusiasts.
- Weekly sessions help maintain focus and allow questions to develop.
- Increased confidence in sharing ideas and getting feedback.
- Practical learning valued, including Linux use, command line tools, and system understanding.
- Curated choices and suggested directions reduce overwhelm.
- Interest in creative outputs and applied work.
- Community-facing projects seen as motivating, including a local website for the local area.
- Laptop reuse and resale viewed positively.
Yellow: emerging issues / areas needing development
- Mixed experience levels among participants.
- Need for differentiation between beginners and more experienced attendees.
- Desire to work more deeply on a single topic rather than covering many.
- Strong interest in privacy, security, and tracking, but recognition that research and myth-busting are needed.
- Need to frame security topics carefully to remain empowering.
Red: risks / constraints to manage
- Lack of clear pathways may reduce momentum if sessions feel too open-ended.
- Risk of privacy and security discussions becoming overwhelming or anxiety-inducing.
- Loss of tacit digital skills when changing tools or platforms.
Computer Club feedback (handwritten notes)
Participant A
- Meeting people.
- Good level of interest.
- Lots of ideas for community projects.
- Local website project.
- Liked selling laptops.
Participant B
- Interest in privacy and security.
- Linux as private by default.
- VPN use to discourage tracking.
- Concerns about AI, social media security, and fingerprinting.
- Avoiding tracking.
- Need for myth-busting and research.
- Social contact for computer enthusiasts.
- Interest in alternative online and in-person events.
- Federated platforms as examples rather than forums.
Participant C
- Building confidence in ideas.
- Getting feedback and reality checks.
- Updating coding practices, including AI tools.
- Desire to spend more time on one topic.
- Weekly sessions help focus and support questions.
Participant E
- Experience using Linux.
- Use of rsync and command line tools.
- Developing a feel for systems and demystifying processes.
- Valued suggested directions and curated choices.
Updates on people’s projects
Participant F
- Feels proud and confident using their current computer setup.
- Notes that many tacit skills are lost.
- Taking notes and happy to pick up tips.
- Determined to persist.
- Working on transferring photos.
- Suggested separate provision for confident users and beginners.
Participant G
- Interest in a local website as a unifying project.
- Possible links with schools.
- Concerns about home page structure.
- Email as a topic.
- Security can be difficult to keep empowering without becoming negative.
Participant H
- Interested in making graphics.
- In response, tools such as GIMP, Inkscape, Krita, and other libre graphics software may be useful.
- Potential applications include posters, t-shirts, and logos.